Presidential succession refers to the procedure for replacing the president or vice president in the event of death or some other form of removal. The act, passed in 1947, which states that after the vice president, the order of succession is. The complete line of succession appears on the next page figure. The united states presidential line of succession is the order in which government officials replace the united states president if the president leaves office before an elected successor is inaugurated. Ronald feinman discusses his book, assassinations, threats, and the american. A flaw in the constitution, and an even more flawed presidential succession act, have opened the door to disaster and zorin intends to exploit both weaknesses to their fullest. The result of this chain of events was the enactment of the second presidential succession law. The presidential succession act of 1792, sections 9 and 10 of the larger act relative to the election of the president and vice president full text, provided that the president pro tempore of the senate would be first in line for the presidency should the offices of the president and. Here is what the constitution says about presidential succession. An individual acting as president under this subsection shall continue so to do until the expiration of the then current presidential term, but not after a qualified and priorentitled individual is able to act, except that the removal of the disability of an individual higher on the list contained in paragraph 1 of this subsection or the ability to qualify on the part of an individual. The 1947 law was the third federal statute codifying the line of succession after the president and vice president. Shortly after president roosevelts death, president truman lobbied for a revision of the law and consequently the presidential succession act of 1947 was passed the new law restored the congressional officers to places directly after the vice president, but switched their order from the 1792 act, placing the speaker of the house first and the president pro tempore second.
Mar 26, 2017 it was clear to us that there were real problems in the presidential succession act of 1947. Presidential succession act of 1947 united states statutes at large, 1947, pp. Rewriting the rules of presidential succession the atlantic. The united states presidential succession act is a federal statute establishing the presidential line of succession. The senate won out in the presidential succession act of 1792. The constitutional politics of presidential succession hofstra law. Could joe biden pick barack obama as his running mate. The order of succession is specified in title 3, chapter 1, section 19 of the u. Presidential succession act of 1792 the progressive professor. On this day, february 21, in 1792, congress passed the presidential succession act, giving the duties of the president, in the event of death or incapacitation of both the sitting president and the vice president, to president pro tempore of the united states senate, followed by.
Congressional research service crs, presidential succession. Sep 21, 2016 as legal scholar akhil amar, who had long studied the legalities of succession, told congress during one hearing after 911, the current presidential succession act, 3 u. Article ii, section 1, clause 6 of the united states constitution authorizes congress to enact such a statute. It was enacted at the urging of president harry truman, when, in. Michael dorf is a professor of constitutional law at cornell university. The act provided that the president pro tempore and then the speaker would succeed the vice president. Discussing presidential succession is still considered taboo by many government officials.
The united states presidential succession act is a federal statute establishing the presidential. Its difficult to see presidential succession in a sentence. Presidential succession act of 1947, the speaker of the house and the. The constitution text stipulates that the vice president is to replace the president, but grants to congress the power to determine further succession.
The act outlines both the order of succession and the requirement for one to qualify to be either the president or acting president of the us. The congress may by law provide for the case of removal, death, resignation or inability, both of the president and vice president. Presidential successionthe framework for electing a president and vicepresident every four years is spelled out in the constitution. Utah, he would most likely be and as of 2015, is the president pro tempore of the senate, and, based on the presidential succession act of 1792. As legal scholar akhil amar, who had long studied the legalities of succession, told congress during one hearing after 911, the current presidential succession. The succession act talks about stuff that isnt mentioned in the 25th amendment.
The president recommended two principal changes in the law which places the line of succession in the cabinet. The first such law, from 17921886, put the speaker third in line for the presidency, with the vice president and the president pro tempore of the us senate ahead of him. The line of succession in the united states is clearly specified in the 1947 presidential succession act and less so in the constitutions article ii and 12th, 20th and 25th amendments. Reading this book, i understand tbat might be true. Could joe biden seek to goose his notyetexistent presidential campaign by adding barack obama to the ticket. It was updated in presidential succession act of 1792, then again in 1886 when there had been two occasion when the office of senate pro tempore had been vacant after the death of a preside.
As originally adopted, the constitution was not clear about certain aspects of succession to the presidency in the event something happened to the elected president. The presidential succession law of 1947 addressed the simultaneous disability of both the president and vice president. The presidential succession of 1910 by francisco i. The line of succession is prescribed in the constitution. How long is the line of succession from the president. Section presidential succession and the vice presidency. Various framers of the constitution, such as james madison, criticized the arrangement as being.
Presidential succession act united states house of. Perspectives, contemporary analysis, and 110th congress proposed legislation, assets. The constitution text article ii, section 1, clause 6 stipulates that the vice president is to replace the president, but grants to congress the power to determine. At an impasse, congress adjourned for nine months, thereby risking governmental paralysis in the event of presidential and vicepresidential vacancies.
Presidential succession the heritage guide to the constitution. Just in case you are curious about the legal accuracy of the show, take a look at the presidential succession act of 1947. Under the presidential succession act, kirkman is now president of the united states. The bumping provision may run afoul of the requirement of the presidential succession clause that such officer shall act accordingly as acting president, until the disability be removed. The presidential succession act of 1792, sections 9 and 10 of the larger act relative to the election of the president and vice president full text, provided that the president pro tempore of the senate would be first in line for the presidency should the offices of the president and the vice president both be vacant at the same time.
Perspectives, contemporary analysis, and 110th congress proposed legislation. The succession act of 1947, as amended, and the two constitutional amendments currently govern succession to the presidency. This text was later changed and clarified by section 1 of the 25th amendment. Crs report for congress white house transition project.
Armed with a weapon leftover from the cold war, one long thought to be just a myth, zorin plans to attack. It was clear to us that there were real problems in the presidential succession act of 1947. If the vice president is unable to take the office, the speaker of the house is next in line for the presidency. Order of presidential succession 2016 presidential election. Following passage of the presidential succession act of 1792, the president pro tempore was next in line after the vice president, and followed by the speaker of. The original act of 1792 had placed the senate president pro tempore and speaker of the house in the line of succession, but in 1886 congress had removed them. Terms in this set 24 presidential succession act of 1947. Sep 30, 2016 just in case you are curious about the legal accuracy of the show, take a look at the presidential succession act of 1947. The presidential succession act refers only to other officers acting as president rather than becoming president. It was enacted at the urging of president harry truman, when, in the dangerous environment just after. How was the order of the united states presidential line of. On this day in 1947, president harry truman signed the presidential succession act, which remains the law of the land.
Designated survivor and the presidential succession act. Speakership is, under madisons reading, to pull the constitutional rug out from. Perspectives, contemporary analysis, and 110th congress proposed legislation october 3, 2008 thomas h. The presidential line of succession established that the vice president would assume the presidency if the president should be unable to serve out his term. Presidential succession act of 1947 ticonderogasummer. Congress may by law provide for the case of removal, death, resignation or inability, both of the president and vice president, declaring what officer shall then act as. In the united states, a designated survivor or designated successor is a named individual in the presidential line of succession, chosen to stay at a secure and undisclosed location away from events such as state of the union addresses and presidential inaugurations.
In the presidential succession act of 1947, lawmakers stipulated that if both positions are empty, power passes first to the speaker of the house or, if she, too, does not survive, to the. That is precisely why the current line of succession is no safer than playing presidential roulette. The line of succession then extended to the executive department heads in the order in which their agencies were created. Early in the second congress, on february 20, 1792, the senate joined the house in passing the presidential succession acta compromise measure that placed in the line of succession its. No constitutional narrative provision existed for filling a vice presidential vacancy. For example, the act as currently written does not place anyone in the line of succession who is not based in the d. The speaker of the house of representatives is second in line for the presidency after the vice president under the presidential succession act of 1947, the third such law. Yale law school yale law school legal scholarship repository. The presidential succession act of 1947 set the order of succession following the vice president. The 1947 law reinserted those officials, but placed the speaker ahead of the president pro tempore. The practice of designating a successor is intended to safeguard continuity in the office of the president in the event the. On july 18, 1947, president harry truman signed the presidential succession act.
The succession question could have been controlled, under the constitution, by a law passed specially for the purpose. Under this law, here are the offices and current office holders who would become president should both the president and vice president be disabled. If the president and the vicepresident are dead, incapacitated or otherwise unable to exercise the powers of the office of president, here is the order of succession. This book is brought to you for free and open access by the twentyfifth amendment archive at flash. Presidential succession act presidential succession refers to the procedure for replacing the president or vice president in the event of death or some other form of removal.
The senate should update the presidential succession act by naming its majority leader as president. Presidential succession act of 1947 congressional timeline. An act to provide for the performance of the duties of the office of president in case of the removal, resignation, death, or inability both of the president and vice president. The presidential succession act of 1947 expanded the line of succession to the following. Law of i886 the presidential succession act of i886, which was on the. Arthur assumed presidential power, the democrats controlled the senate. After that, it would be presumed that whatever remains of the u. He has spoken and frequently written about the presidential succession act, and he has introduced a bill, h. Presidential succession is outlined in the constitution of the united states, and further refined in the presidential succession act of 1947. Akhil reed amar and vikram david amar in this essay, akhil and vikram amar attack the constitutionality of the current presidential succession statute, which places the speaker of the house and the senate president pro.
720 1425 630 347 236 333 1190 1023 9 132 323 358 209 1065 96 608 1080 1120 1310 1276 1476 1177 92 566 446 1245 1006 868 459 1309 1462 552 1267 465 1059 761 158 242 1216